Most homeowners shop for new kitchen countertops, thinking only about what works for their lifestyle right now. You’re already ahead of the curve. By considering resale value, you’re asking the smarter question: “Will this surface also help me sell later?” The truth is, not every countertop material adds value the same way.
At Cutting Edge Countertops, we complete more than 15,000 projects a year. That kind of experience has shown us exactly which countertop choices catch a buyer’s eye and which ones don’t.
What Home Buyers Want in Countertops
When it comes to resale, the countertop you choose isn’t just about your taste—it’s about how a future buyer will read your kitchen the second they walk in. Here’s what today’s home buyers expect to see:
1. Durability matters most
Buyers want a durable countertop that stands up to daily life—scratches from knives, stains from spills, and hot pots straight from the stove. A surface that looks worn too quickly can signal “expensive repairs ahead” to a potential buyer.
2. Low maintenance is a selling point
Busy families don’t want to deal with constant upkeep. Countertops that wipe clean with just soap and water—and don’t need frequent sealing—are much more attractive than ones that require special care.
3. Timeless design beats trendy looks
Bold colors may feel personal, but neutral stone countertop materials and classic veining have broader buyer appeal. When buyers can picture their own style blending into your kitchen, resale value goes up.
4. Buyers connect cost with quality
Most buyers know that granite, quartz, or marble can run between $100 and $150 per square foot or even more. They see those materials as true investments, not quick fixes. Choosing these options shows you’ve put lasting value into your home.
What are the Best Countertop Materials for Resale?
Not every countertop adds the same weight when a buyer walks through your kitchen or bathroom. Some instantly signal “this home is updated and worth more,” while others can leave buyers underwhelmed. Here’s how the most popular countertop materials stack up for resale:
1. Granite Countertops
Granite is one of the best kitchen countertops for resale because buyers already know it’s a durable, natural stone. They see it as an upgrade over laminate or tile. Each slab is unique, which adds to its appeal, though it does require sealing to protect against stains. For many buyers, granite still feels like a safe, timeless investment.
If you’re considering granite, professional installation makes all the difference in the seams and finish. Find out why professional granite countertop installation is worth it.
2. Quartz Countertops (Engineered Surface)
Quartz countertops consistently rank among the best countertop materials for resale. They’re non-porous, resist stains, and come in a wide range of hues to fit any kitchen design. Buyers like that quartz combines beauty and low maintenance, making it a favorite in modern kitchens and full remodels.
We’ve compared quartz against other popular stones to help homeowners weigh the differences. See our full quartz vs. granite guide here.
3. Quartzite
For buyers who love the look of marble but want more durability, quartzite is a standout. It’s a natural stone, heat-resistant, and long-lasting. Its elegant veining adds luxury, and that “high-end” factor draws attention from buyers looking for a dream kitchen or bathroom.
4. Marble Countertops (Selective Use)
Marble countertops still carry a luxury reputation. When buyers see marble in a powder room or master bath, they instantly associate the home with elegance. While marble requires more care in kitchens, it still boosts resale in the right spaces—especially for homeowners who want to showcase sophistication.
Curious how marble stacks up against quartz in real kitchens? Read our quartz vs. marble comparison.
5. Porcelain / Ultra-Compact Surfaces
Porcelain slabs and ultra-compact surfaces are gaining momentum. They’re lightweight, resistant to UV rays, stains, and scratches, and they don’t need sealing. For resale, they appeal to buyers who want sleek, modern kitchens or outdoor spaces with low-maintenance durability.
We’ve broken down porcelain against quartz to help homeowners understand the differences in maintenance and design. Quartz vs. porcelain countertops: which one is best?
Some homeowners choose butcher block countertops or laminate countertops, thinking they’re saving money. And in the short term, they are. But when it comes to resale, those savings can backfire.
Buyers rarely see these surfaces as upgrades. Instead, they read them as budget choices, which can actually lower the value of your home compared to granite, quartz, or other stone countertop materials.
What Are the Factors That Maximize the Resale Value?
Choosing the right countertop isn’t just about picking granite over quartz or marble over porcelain. Resale value depends on how the material fits into the bigger picture of your home. Here are four factors that matter most to home buyers:
- Neutral over bold. When it comes to resale, timeless countertops always win. Neutral tones like whites, grays, and beiges let buyers picture their dream kitchen more easily. Bright or unusual colors might match your style now, but can limit your home’s appeal later.
- Match the space. A full kitchen remodel with quartz countertops can deliver great ROI, but that same investment in a small half-bath may not move the needle. The right material should feel appropriate for the room, not out of balance.
- Maintenance expectations. Buyers know the pros and cons of different surfaces. A porous stone that requires sealing might still add value, but a non-porous surface signals “low maintenance.” Understanding upkeep is part of why buyers prefer quartz over marble or laminate when they’re comparing options.
- Professional installation matters. Even the best kitchen countertop loses appeal if it’s not installed properly. Buyers can tell when seams don’t line up or edges look unfinished. Quality countertop installation not only makes the space look polished, but it also reassures buyers that they won’t face costly fixes later.
Keep these factors in mind, and you’ll not only enjoy your countertops today, you’ll also increase the value of your home when it’s time to sell.
Need inspiration? Check out our latest roundup of trending countertop colors. Trending color round-up.
Conclusion
When it comes to resale, the safest bets remain granite and quartz. They’ve proven to be the best countertop choices for kitchens and bathrooms because buyers know their value. Still, other surfaces like quartzite, marble, and porcelain can also increase the value of your home when used in the right spaces.
The best way to find the best countertop isn’t just reading about them—it’s seeing the slabs in person. Visit a Cutting Edge Countertops showroom, explore a wide range of countertops for your kitchen, and let our team help you find the best choice that fits your lifestyle today and resale goals tomorrow.
FAQs About Countertops and Resale Value
1. Which countertop adds the most resale value to a kitchen?
Quartz and granite are the safest bets for resale value. Buyers recognize them as premium materials, and both signal durability and quality. High-end options like quartzite and marble can also boost appeal in the right spaces.
2. Do quartz countertops increase the value of your home?
Yes. Quartz countertops are non-porous, durable, and low-maintenance—all qualities that home buyers want. Because quartz combines beauty with practicality, it’s seen as an investment that can increase the value of your home during resale.
3. Is granite still a good countertop material choice for resale?
Absolutely. Granite remains one of the most trusted kitchen countertops for home buyers. Its natural beauty, heat resistance, and longevity make it the best countertop material for kitchens and baths. Regular sealing protects against stains and keeps its value high.
4. Should I avoid butcher block if I plan to resell?
Yes, if resale value is your priority. Butcher block countertops add warmth but are prone to scratches and stains, which buyers often see as extra upkeep. They’re less likely to be viewed as an upgrade compared to stone countertops.
5. What colors of countertops are best for resale?
Neutral tones, such as white, gray, and beige, are the best countertop colors for resale. They create a timeless look that appeals to a wide range of home buyers. Bold or trendy hues may feel personal, but often limit resale appeal.